RDR2 Hosea Crime Novel: Location, Request & Reward

Hosea Matthews’s camp item request in RDR2 is a crime novel called The Case of the Shrew in the Fog, which can be found in the Hagen Orchards in Bayou Nwa. Let’s see how to trigger and find this request item in no time.
Table of Contents
Hosea Crime Novel Location in RDR2
Hosea’s crime novel camp item request is located on the table in the Hagen Orchards house, which is located all the way toward the southeastern part of the map, in Bayou Nwa, north of Saint Denis.


When you enter the house, the table is near the door, so when you open it, you’ll spot it with no problem.

Watch out for the guard who patrols Hagen Orchards. He can turn hostile when you enter the property, so you can silence him if you wish or if you don’t want anything that costs you honor, just hogtie him. Then you can find The Case of the Shrew in the Fog, which is another book in the Aldous Filson series.
Funny thing is, these mystery stories and the character of Aldous Filson are Rockstar’s playful take on the kind of detective fiction Sir Arthur Conan Doyle made famous through his Sherlock Holmes stories in the late 1800s and early 1900s.
How to Trigger Hosea’s Crime Novel Request in RDR2
You can trigger Hosea’s crime novel request in Chapters 2-4, between 8 AM and 8 PM. Since it’s missable, I’d complete it in Chapter 2 rather than leave it until the last minute. To trigger his request, you should pick up the crime novel called The Case of the Deceitful German from Hosea’s things at the camp. When you do that, the camp item request automatically appears in your tasks.


Since Hosea enjoys reading crime novels, it’s about time Arthur found him another crime novel.
How to Complete Hosea’s Crime Novel Request
So, it’s time to head back and give Hosea his next piece of entertainment. Find and interact with him, then select “Give Request.” It’s interesting because when Arthur gives Hosea the book, he mentions Hosea might like this author. To which Hosea replies yes and that he hasn’t read this book yet.
Hosea thanks Arthur for the book and rewards him with Predator Bait, which he leaves at Arthur’s tent for you to collect.
Hosea Crime Novel Request Not Completing? How to Fix It
If Hosea’s request still appears in your log after you’ve given him the book, check Arthur’s tent for the Predator Bait reward. You may need to leave camp and return before it appears. When you pick up the reward, it should clear the request.
And if you have the novel but can’t give it to Hosea, he may be tied to an active story mission. Complete that mission and try talking to him again.



