RDR2 Bandit Challenge 1 Guide: Hold Up 5 Townsfolk

The first Bandit Challenge is straightforward and serves as a gentle introduction to the full set. You simply need to hold up five townsfolk inside settlement limits. Progress only counts once the challenge is active, and you can spread the hold-ups out over time if you prefer.
You’ll Read:
How to Hold Up Townsfolk
Target any civilian inside a town or settlement. Aim your weapon at them and select the Rob option. You may need to threaten them a couple of times until they hand over cash or valuables. Keep them under control until the exchange finishes. If they escape or run off before giving you anything, it does not count.
Not every person will cooperate. Armed NPCs often fight back, so stick to unarmed civilians whenever possible. Shopkeepers also work well: enter a store, aim at the shopkeeper, and choose the rob option when it appears.
Best Locations


Valentine and Strawberry are the strongest choices because of their lighter law presence. Isolated porches, quiet side streets and alleyways make it easy to complete a hold-up without drawing a crowd.

Alleyways in Saint Denis at night are another solid option if you prefer a denser town. Look for people sitting alone or walking in less-trafficked spots. Wear a bandana or mask before you start to lower the chance of being identified by witnesses.
Tips for Smooth Progress
- Stay inside town limits. Robbing people on open roads or outside settlements will not count.
- Do the hold-ups one at a time and leave the area if lawmen start closing in. You do not need to finish all five in a single session.
- If a witness tries to report you, you can stop them as well, but it is usually cleaner to pick quiet targets from the start.
- Save beforehand if you want a clean reload option in case things escalate.
Reward

Bandit Bandolier is the reward here. Once you complete the challenge, the Bandit Bandolier becomes available for purchase at any Trapper. It forms the first piece of the full Bandit equipment set.



