RDR2 Sharpshooter 2: How to Kill Two Different Animals in One Dead Eye

RDR2 Sharpshooter 2 asks you to kill two different animal species during a single Dead Eye activation. The shooting is the easy part. Finding two different critters standing near each other is what takes forever. The reward is a measly $5 and 25 Dead Eye XP, and you need to finish Sharpshooter 1 first, or nothing you kill counts. No headshots or named weapons are required. You just need the right setup.
What You’ll Read:
How to Complete RDR2 Sharpshooter 2
Don’t rush the setup. Burning your Dead Eye meter on a bad pair is the real time sink.
- Confirm Sharpshooter 2 is your active challenge in the challenge menu. Kills from before it unlocks don’t count.
- Equip a repeater with enough rounds for both animals. A Varmint Rifle works for birds. Skip the Springfield, which holds one round.
- Find two clearly different species close together, like a deer and a rabbit. Carry a tonic so your meter is ready when you spot them.
- Aim, enter Dead Eye, and mark both animals, with scope view off. Buttons are in the next section.
- Fire only after both are marked. Shoot early, and Dead Eye ends after one kill. Headshots help, but any lethal hit counts.

Dead Eye Controls for Marking Targets
These are the default inputs. Use your own bindings if you remapped them.
| Action | PlayStation | Xbox | PC |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enter Dead Eye while aiming | Click R3 | Click right stick | Caps Lock or middle mouse |
| Place a manual mark | R1 | RB | Q |
Before Pouring Forth Oil Part IV in Chapter 2, you don’t place marks at all. Targets get painted automatically as your reticle passes over them. That mission unlocks manual marking, so afterward you press the mark button on each animal yourself.
The mission isn’t required for this challenge. Still, automatic marking is more forgiving, so I’d finish Sharpshooter 2 before it if you can.
What Counts and What Doesn’t
A deer and a rabbit count. A doe and a buck don’t, because they’re the same species. Two separate Dead Eye activations don’t count either.
Everything else is flexible. No headshots, flying targets, perfect pelts, or specific weapon needed. A bird can be one of your two animals.
Bows are a gray area. You can’t queue two arrow shots, so I wouldn’t plan around one, unless you can shoot a single arrow killing two animals.
Best Places to Find Two Different Animals
None of these are guaranteed spawns. Check the species before you enter Dead Eye.
| Spot | What to look for | Catch |
|---|---|---|
| Dakota River bank | Walk the bank slowly and wait for two species to show up | No exact point, so expect some waiting |
| Ducks by water | Pekin and Mallard ducks near riverbanks or Heartland Overflow | – |
| Valentine to Horseshoe Overlook | Deer and pronghorn along the railroad tracks | – |
| Emerald Ranch | Goats and chickens | Killing livestock where someone sees it can bring animal cruelty trouble |
| Swamps and plains | Saint Denis swamps, wooded Lemoyne and West Elizabeth, New Hanover plains | Broad areas, but a bird can be the second target |
Dakota River Bank


Emerald Ranch and Heartland Overflow


Valentine to Horseshoe Overlook

Saint Denis Swamps

I’d pick a wild pair over the farm.
Sharpshooter 2 Reward
Rank 2 pays $5 and 25 Dead Eye XP, and that’s all. There’s no gear. The Sharpshooter Bandolier comes from rank 1, and the Sharpshooter Holster unlocks at rank 3. You buy both from any of the five Trapper locations in RDR2 once you’ve earned them. The XP is the only part worth caring about.
Sharpshooter 3 is next and asks for five flying birds from a moving train.
FAQ
Do I need a high Dead Eye level?
No. Dead Eye XP only grows your meter, which is separate from challenge progress. A bigger meter helps, but there is no minimum level.
Do I need to finish any Chapter 4 mission first?
No. A later upgrade lets you keep firing without marks, but you don’t need it. Marking both targets first is enough.
Can I miss Sharpshooter 2 permanently?
No. Sharpshooter challenges aren’t missable, so you can come back to it whenever you find a pair.



