Melvor Idle 2 Money Making: Best Methods After the Launch Patch

Money making in Melvor Idle 2 is something many people are struggling with; especially considering that many things have changed in early access. I dug deep and searched every corner of the internet to find everything I can about money making, so if you have tried the demo and want to know what has changed or you just want to learn best money making methods I have you covered.
In This Guide:
Best Melvor Idle 2 Money Making Methods
| Method | What you need | Evidence | GP/hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keyed Locked Thug Chest | Completed Thug Chest Key; Thieving 10 for the chest, 15 for the Thug Chief | Several players use it now; the rate is modeled | About 66,000 (fan model, not timed) |
| Deep Blue Fishing | Fishing 98 | A Reddit post and a fan guide land close together | About 165,000–175,000 with no bonuses (calculated, not timed) |
| Dawnsteel Two-Handed Sword (Smithing) | Mining and Smithing, around level 79 | One commenter’s claim, disputed | Claimed 119,000 (not confirmed) |
| Meteorite Bars and Boots | Mining and Smithing, around level 80 | Unrepeated claims, limited supply | Claimed 522,000 (bars) and up to 681,000 (boots), not confirmed |
| Selling iron or steel bars | Mining and Smithing | One player report, no hourly time | Unknown |
| Cooking (like Strawberry Cakes) | A stockpile of ingredients | Players warn the supply runs out | Unknown |
| Giant Chicken | Combat | Cut by the feather nerf, no timed rate since | No current rate |
| Rabbit Hunting, Goblin dungeon, Gusty Cliffside | Varies | Single suggestions, untested | Unknown |
“Unknown” means nobody has posted a timed test yet. “Claimed” means one player said it and nobody repeated it.
How to Make Money Early in Melvor Idle 2
What Changed in the Launch Patch
Feathers now sell for 1 GP instead of 4. Crafted jewelry from Topaz through Emerald sells for more, and so do early Runecrafting wands and staves. Slimes and Bees pay more GP. Quest GP is doubled, and old saves get the difference when they load. The devs also added Astrology, Herblore and Agility, plus more Mastery Guild ranks and permanent shop upgrades.
Quest Gold and Price Buffs Aren’t a Farm
Quest gold is one-time cash for your progress, not a farm. The same goes for selling a stockpile right after you load an old save: it tells you nothing about hourly income. Demo saves carry over, and the devs describe a reset-to-level-60 option for overlevelled XP.

Best Early Money Ladder for New Characters
On a brand-new character, Thieving only opens at Cooking 10, so you start with Stone gear from Smithing at about 4,000 GP/hour. Once you’re past that, it ranks the best-paid action at each stage with modeled, no-bonus rates: Thieving Citizens at level 1 (about 6,800 GP/hour), Thugs at level 5 (about 9,600), Iron Two-Handed Swords at level 15 (about 12,400), and Silver Topaz Amulets at level 20 (about 23,200).
Why Your Shop Won’t Unlock
Watch what your unlocks need. You might have plenty of combat GP and still being unable to open the Shop until you sell more items. The Shop needs 250 GP earned from item sales, and Ranching needs 20,000 GP from sales plus 200 Normal Logs cut. Coins from combat, Thieving and quests don’t count.
How to Farm Locked Thug Chests
The Locked Thug Chest in Lowtown District is the method players bring up most since launch. In the Reddit thread, people call it competitive but admit the best Early Access route isn’t settled.
Requirements and Key Setup
It isn’t an instant starter farm, though. Thieving only unlocks at Cooking 10. The chest needs Thieving 10 and the Thug Chief needs 15, and you need food and enough hitpoints while you set it up. This is what you should do:
- Get Thug Chest Key Part A from the Thug Chief. It’s a rare drop.
- Open the Locked Thug Chest with lockpicks until the other half drops.
- Combine both halves in the bank.
- Equip the finished key.

What the Thug Chest Key Does
Once equipped, the key adds +500 Stealth and +50 Fortune, but only on this chest. Demo players saw the Topaz amount per drop go from 5–10 to 7–15 with 50 Fortune. Success hits 100% here, and normal use doesn’t use the key up. Don’t assume the same for other chests. Other sources model less than 100% on the later Bank and Beast chests, even with their own keys.
How to Get the Second Key Half
Getting the second half is the difficult part. Each attempt costs a lockpick, even if you fail. Thugs drop lockpicks, and the main quest, The Path to Melvor, gives you 1,000. One Reddit player used about 1,200 lockpicks before the second half dropped. Another guessed it’s around 1 in 500.

Best Gear and Income
For gear, I suggest using Bandit Gloves, the Thug Armband and the Slime Getaway shop upgrade. One player called overnight farming with the gloves and armband their best AFK income, it doesn’t hurt to try it.
The chest’s coin reward is small, and that confuses people. But know that the money is in selling the loot. The fan model gives about 66,268 GP/hour, with about half from coins and common drops and the rest from four or five rare drops an hour. So short sessions can swing a lot.
Spare Keys and Overnight Safety
Spare completed keys sold for around 34,000–37,000 GP in the demo. One player worked out that farming extra keys on purpose adds under 2% income, so I’d just sell the extras you get.
Keep two jobs apart: farming the key can fail and waste food and lockpicks, while farming the keyed chest is the low-maintenance part. Getting knocked out while Thieving can destroy an item in your toolbelt, which could be your key. Check your success chance, food and gear before you leave it running overnight.
Is Giant Chicken Still Worth It?
Not as the obvious pick anymore. Giant Chicken is a Combat enemy in the Farmlands, not a Hunting target. In the Demo you could get roughly 60,000–85,000 GP/hour from it. Then the patch cut feathers from 4 GP to 1 GP.
How Much Did the Feather Nerf Cost?
That’s a 75% cut on feathers, not on the whole income. One Reddit player posted their demo loot: 119,511 feathers, 16,120 Raw Chicken, 4,337 Big Bones and 150,135 direct GP over about 10 hours 14 minutes of fighting, worth 695,115 GP in all. Drop the feathers from 4 GP to 1 GP and you lose 358,533 GP. That leaves 336,582 GP, about 52% less, not 75%.

So it isn’t nothing, but it’s weaker than before.
What to Farm Instead of Giant Chicken
You can go with the Thug Chest, Steppe Rabbit Hunting, or the Goblin dungeon, where you keep the cheap food and Big Bones and sell the rest.
Deep Blue Fishing at Level 98
Deep Blue is the Fishing spot you unlock at Fishing 98. With no bonuses you can get about 175,000 GP/hour, and about 95% of that comes from common fish, not rare jackpots.
[IMAGE 2: The Fishing area list showing Deep Blue and its Fishing 98 requirement. If you can’t reach it yet, show it locked. File name: melvor idle 2 deep blue fishing level 98]
How to Reach Fishing 98
The problematic part is level. The checkpoints are Pebble Bank at Fishing 23, Sea Edge at 55, Gusty Cliffside at 67, Glowing Rift at 78, Shark Cove at 88, then Deep Blue at 98. It takes about 269 hours of fishing from a new character to get there.
Do Bonuses Change the Deep Blue Rate?
A lot. The fan guide has 229,635 with half the bonuses and 311,220 with every bonus. That last one is a ceiling, because the guide takes the best item for each bonus even where items share a slot. One player with a lot of playtime also says high-level Fishing pays well.
Fishing Upgrades and Rare Drops
If you can’t find the Copper Reel or Wooden Fishing Pole after buying them, you should know that they’re permanent Fishing upgrades, not inventory items. I suggest an Agility detour to level 10 and 200 tokens for the novice fishing set. Don’t count on Torn Ancient Sailcloth from Gusty Cliffside either. It’s a rare drop, and one lucky sale isn’t an hourly rate.

So Deep Blue is a target, not a day-one answer. Use the chest to fund your way there.
Should You Cook or Craft Items Before You Sell?
There are two different questions here. The first is “I already have the ingredients, is cooking worth it?” That’s easy to check: compare what the cooked item sells for with what the raw items sell for.
Cooking and the Ingredient Problem
The second is “Can I do this forever?” That needs the whole loop, gathering included. I suggest Strawberry Cakes but I also know it’s hard to supply enough ingredients. A Steam player says to always process everything before selling, but someone replied that not every chain pays. A demo-era player reported a huge Chicken Sandwich rate, then warned that Lettuce, Onion and Bread run out first.
Crafting and Jewelry
Crafting has the same problem. One demo thread claims about 120,000 GP/hour for Snakeskin Farm Gloves but leaves out gathering. Another player puts it at 80,000–100,000 with gathering. Same item, different math.
Jewelry has a patch-confirmed buff, and the chest gives you materials to process. One player makes ruby jewelry instead of selling raw rubies, and another notes that Silver Bars drop along the way. Early wands and staves got a buff too. Nobody has tested whether any of it beats simply selling.
Smithing Chains and Upgrades
Smithing is the other contender. A Steam player explains that Mining upgrades, preservation, doubling and step skipping stack across mining, smelting and smithing. They model Dragon Platebody at about 27,000 GP/hour with no upgrades, 107,000 with shop upgrades and 179,000 with more bonuses. But they link the same fan guide, so that isn’t a second source.
Dawnsteel and Meteorite Claims
One Reddit commenter claims 119,000 GP/hour for a full Dawnsteel Two-Handed Sword chain around level 79. The poster of the Fishing thread questioned the ore, coal and crafting assumptions, and nobody settled it. Another commenter claims 522,000 GP/hour for Meteorite Bars and up to 681,000 for Meteorite Boots, then warns that Meteorite is finite and shouldn’t be smelted before your masteries are ready.
So Should You Cook or Craft?
So cook or craft to clear a stockpile. For a long-term route, count every hour it takes to make the stockpile.
How to Check Your Actual GP Per Hour
Track What Your Action Earns
The game has a Codex for item sources and uses, and Current Action Tracking, which shows hourly items gained and used. Run one action and look at what it made and what it burned through. Then multiply by what you actually sell for.

How to Calculate Net GP Per Hour
Use one number you can repeat: net GP per hour. That’s cash plus what you actually sell, minus what you bought and used up (lockpicks, food, ammo), divided by every hour you spent gathering, making, fighting and restocking. If you’re processing stock you already own, the real gain is the processed sale value minus what the raw stock would have sold for, minus any extra inputs. Don’t count Big Bones as sold and kept for Prayer at the same time. Write down your game build and the date too, since Early Access will keep changing. And run it long enough that one lucky rare drop doesn’t fool you.
Is an Upgrade Worth Buying?
The same math tells you if an upgrade is worth buying: divide its cost by the extra net GP/hour it gives you. For example, a 5,000 GP upgrade that lifts your income from 10,000 to 12,000 GP/hour pays itself back in 2.5 hours. Those are made-up numbers to show the math, not an in-game quote.
Why You Earn Less Than Guides Say
If you earn less than a guide says, it’s usually one of three things. Guides can count bonuses you don’t have yet, like shop upgrades, Mastery Guild ranks, Astrology nodes, pets and outfits. They can count rare drops differently: the chest’s 66,000 includes four or five rare drops an hour, while the Deep Blue number leaves rare drops out. And some figures just skip gathering time.

